First American Title Insurance Co. President Sally Tyler to Step Down

Sally French Tyler, president of First American Title Insurance Company, will retire at the end of 2026 after been with the company since 2005. Tyler became president of its National Commercial Services division where she more than doubled its operating revenue and helped build it into one of the nation’s largest commercial title and settlement operations. She was appointed as President of First American Title Insurance Company in 2025 where she had overall responsibility for the company’s direct, agency and commercial title operations.

Under Tyler’s leadership, the Title Insurance and Services segment increased revenue 22% in 2025, while full-year commercial revenue reached $1 billion, up 32% from the prior year.
​
“Sally’s impact on First American and the title industry is difficult to overstate,” said Mark Seaton, CEO of First American. “She is an exceptional business leader who understands our customers, cares deeply about our people and has helped shape First American into the company it is today.”